The truth, what’s good and what’s not

Hospitality from John and Mike is exceptional! They offer thoughtful island tips and have a small pool for relaxation.

Some rooms felt a bit restrictive with space! Parking can be limited, so planning a rental is crucial.

I mean, I suppose being close to the ferry is a plus, but why was every restaurant closed? I don’t understand how I had to deal with tight space in the Standard Queen Room—deplorable! And forget expecting a welcome treat for my stay, it's ridiculous. I almost thought about writing a glowing review but just couldn't.

Incredible welcome from the staff and fantastic recommendations.

The room we were in felt very cramped for our four nights there, especially with limited space for our luggage. While it was nice having amenities, I expected more comfort for the price we paid. The location was not optimal with many restaurants being closed, making it difficult to find good dining options during our stay.

Exceptional owners' hospitality!

Loved the heated pool and shared kitchen, but laundry was inconvenient to access.

The warm hospitality made the stay exceptional, with Mike providing tailored recommendations that significantly enriched our experience on the island. The quiet location offered serenity while still being within walking distance of great dining options. However, the limited parking made it challenging to maneuver, and while the communal kitchen was well-equipped, access to laundry facilities felt a bit inconvenient at times. Make sure to indulge in grilled seafood at nearby restaurants for an unforgettable meal.

the warmth of amazing hosts like john and mike makes this paradise unforgettable

Casa de Amistad is a gem! The owners, John and Mike, create a unique atmosphere that blends comfort with community. Their thoughtful care and local insights truly enhance your stay. Beach chairs and coolers are provided for your adventures. It's not just the beautiful garden and inviting pool that make it special. it's the genuine hospitality that made us feel so welcomed. Highly recommend!

John went above and beyond to ensure I had access to a doctor when I fell ill, which made a significant impact on my well-being during the trip. The fresh papaya from the courtyard was an unexpected delight.

Perfect base for exploring the island!

The vibe of the place is really chill, with a great kitchen and communal areas, but what stood out the most was the hospitality of Mike and John. They shared all the best spots to check out and even had beach gear ready for us to borrow,, which was unexpected but totally awesome.

It wasn’t exactly a bargain, but for the value we got, it was acceptable.

Loved the beach gear, cozy rooms, and the amazing shared kitchen! The serene atmosphere allowed for some relaxing moments.

Loved my stay in the Standard Queen Room! Enjoyed the clean pool, cozy balcony, and free beach gear. Plus, the location is perfect for exploring all around the island!

I adored the beautiful gardens that created a tranquil oasis, while the comfortable pool area offered a perfect spot to relax after exploring. The welcoming communal spaces encouraged conversations, making it ideal for socializing with fellow guests.

More seating options in communal areas would be nice.